Mariners STH Photo Day, And Statistical First Place

Yesterday was a good day. I mean, a really really good day.

It started with me getting a ton of sleep, which is rare. I had a cup of coffee at home, got ready, ran some errands, then took the car home, packed my bag with the stuff I would need for a day out, and headed to RealFine to grab a cold brew espresso, because it was pretty warm out in the direct sunlight. I had a small collapsible umbrella for shade, but I wear a lot of black so it was still a little warm. All coffee’d up, I hit the bus stop and grabbed the 50 down to SoDo, where I walked to Henry’s near Safeco and had a nice leisurely lunch. The grilled chicken Caesar there is great, in case you were wondering.

Daniel met me there, polished off a watermelon sour, and then we headed for the right field gates for…Season Ticket Holder PHOTO DAY! I have never done this before, as I didn’t think much of it, and am not an autograph hound or a fan who needs to meet players; I’m just interested in the game. Plus, in a long line of people, how much can the players actually get done? It just seemed to be kind of a pointless endeavor, generally speaking.

Until I actually did it, and now I’m sold.

Daniel and I got through the RF gates, got our Nelson Cruz Funko Pop!s (mine is the white uniform, which is great because it matches my white uniform Felix one from last year), and headed down a ramp to go to the field level, assisted along the way by staff. If you have ever done the Refuse to Abuse 5K, it was that same tunnel you get to just before you get out of the center field wall, which was how we got on the field. We were given overall instructions on where might be the best place to stand, and found an open spot along the roped-off grass on the warning track, then discovered that our friends (Maple Grove members, all) were over towards right field, so we wandered over there instead. Hugs and greetings were had, and we all stood around chatting with each other and people around us while waiting for the players to come out.

When it was time, some of the old school players were introduced; Bill Kreuger, Ryan Rowland-Smith, Erik Hanson, Julio Cruz, and Mike Blowers were on hand, and went out to various parts of the field to make their rounds. Then the current players came out of the clubhouse with handlers to make sure they were being as timely as possible. And when I say current players, I mean everyone. Even Ichiro was out there, though I will just say right now that there was no way he, Felix, or James Paxton were ever going to make it around the entire field (and they didn’t).

IMG_5437.JPGLook ma! I’m on the field! Again.

We waited until people came around, and made executive decisions on whether to do singular selfies with each player or group shots as so to try to help them make best use of their time. Because of the sun, some photos didn’t come out so great, and because we were using our phones (to further avoid taking up too much time as people figured out how to use a random camera), or giving them to the handlers to try and get photos facing into the sun, a lot of these didn’t come out as well as I personally would have liked. But it was stupid amounts of fun. So here are some pictures I got…

IMG_5438.JPGTiffany and Daniel with Ryan Cook. It was Tiffany’s birthday yesterday, I was glad to be present for it.

IMG_5439.JPGTiffany, myself, and the top of Daniel’s head with Ryon Healy, who was super sweet and took a few seconds more with us than he probably needed to.

IMG_5441.JPGNelson Cruuuuuuuuuuz! Daniel, Tiffany, me, Su, Rachel, Allie, and some dude in back of us who actually photobombed another picture that was taken later. Cruz left quite an impression on Daniel, who said he had a gentle handshake (Daniel’s goal there was to shake everyone’s hand).

IMG_5444Jean Segura! Daniel’s mom Mitzi is next to him, then the rest of us. Please excuse the handler’s thumb.

IMG_5445.JPGJames Pazos and the Unholy Lens Flare.

IMG_5448.JPGMiiiiike Zunino! I have been pulling for this guy since he was drafted and I’m so happy he’s finally come into his own lately. Also super friendly.

IMG_5452.JPGBen Gamel. He was really sweet, stood around chatting for a while longer than he needed to.

IMG_5454.JPGFirst base coach Chris Prieto.

IMG_5455.JPGTechnically speaking, you could get a photo with Ryan Rowland-Smith just about any time he’s at the ROOT Sports desk, so long as you ask nicely, I’d imagine. But this was too good an opportunity to pass up, and he’s such a nice guy. I’d say all our little faces demonstrate how excited we were to be there. The next two are my favorite; Kyle Seager and Edwin Diaz. How insanely cool is this?

IMG_5456.JPGIMG_5457It’s not every day you get to say hi to the closer, and it’s been a while since we’ve had a closer I’ve really loved. Seager verified that the players can hear our chants and songs when we gather as the Maple Grove for James Paxton starts, and the “Corey’s brother” thing is still cool, but told us that if we do one chant and he doesn’t get a hit, we need to switch it up. Superstition is definitely a thing in baseball.

IMG_5459.JPGManager Scott Servais. I have really liked him since he’s been here. He has the demeanor of Don Wakamatsu, who has been my favorite manager since I’ve been a fan. Sorry, Allie, I know your eyes are closed but this is the only picture the handler took on my phone. Hopefully you have a better one!

IMG_5460.JPGMe and Mitzi and Erasmo Ramirez, who said he’s been feeling better lately and should be ready to go soon. We also met several other players and staff, but didn’t get pictures with everyone. In retrospect, I should have taken a picture with Erik Hanson, but I try to be cognizant of people’s personal space and if they didn’t seem like they wanted their photo taken, or were walking farther from the rope than other players, I didn’t ask. One thing I was struck by, however, is how small a lot of players actually are. When I used to hang out down in the Pen taking pictures of JJ, Vargas, and Morrow, they were all pretty large guys. Kyle Seager is just a regular-sized person, and it was nice to get that kind of perspective. It makes them more human, not just some people I watch on TV all summer. Nelson Cruz, however, is a massive human being; the “Boom Stick” thing is not just a cute nickname.

We were maybe 20 yards or so from James Paxton and even less from Mitch Haniger, but it was time for the event to end so they could get everyone off the field and prep the field for the game. We were filed out back into the CF tunnel and into The Pen, which was perfect because by that time, I desperately needed some water. Daniel and I headed to Edgar’s, but were stopped short due to a medical emergency inside. John, the door guy down there who is super nice and doesn’t card me or Daniel anymore, was kind enough to get me some water, though, which was so very appreciated after standing in the sun for so long. After a few minutes, they let us into the top part near the bar, and I was able to fill my water bottle up more and Daniel was able to grab a margarita, and Su met us inside, then we decided it was best to leave again because of space and the crowds.

We met more friends down in The Pen (and new friend Terris, who talked to Daniel about hockey for a while and seems like a good chap, all around), and stood around and talked until about 6.30, when we decided to go up and see if a row in the LF bleachers was available for all of us to sit in. Turns out there was, so we sat there and cheered the game on, talked about stats, heckled fans talking about their freaking fantasy teams (guys, nobody gives a damn, I promise) had snacks, and enjoyed the win. The Win! 

So you know what – I know that it’s one win, and I know that it is statistical first place/tie with the Astros for first in the AL West. But in all the time I’ve been a Mariners fan, I have never seen the staff change the flags in the outfield, nor have I seen the flags in first place in JUNE.

IMG_5464.JPGFor most of the time I’ve been a fan, pre-Astros-in-the-AL, it was always Texas and Angels flags up front, with us and the A’s duking it out for last place. This is a nice change.

IMG_5466.JPGNo, your eyes aren’t bad, this photo is kind of blurry. Clockwise; Tommy, Kate, Daniel, Hillary, Joe, Matt, Rachel, Tiffany, me, and Su. These are also some of the main Maple Grove people, so follow up on Twitter if you haven’t already. They’re some of the best baseball friends I could ask for. My only regret was that everyone we know could not have also been here for this, it was a ton of fun.

After we got everything collected and were able to exit the field, some of us decided to go home, while the rest of us decided to go to Flatstick Pub for celebratory drinks. I am taking a dry June, but one glass of champagne won’t kill me, and this was a very special occasion, so I opted for the one glass, and we watched people around us play games while we unwound from all the excitement.

IMG_5468.JPGOh, and also this happened…

So yeah, I get it; it’s like a fraction of a percentage that we are ahead of the Houston Astros right now, and sure, it can change today, or tomorrow, or a week from now. But yesterday was a damn fine day, I’m glad I was alive for it, and I’m not going to allow anyone to tell me I shouldn’t be, simply because there is a difference of 0.03 between us and a team that has been a thorn in our sides since they first showed up in the AL. June 2nd, 2018 was one of the best baseball days I’ve had in my life, and I’m going to remember it until I die or until I can’t remember stuff anymore.

The Mariners are playing their last game in this series against the Tampa Bay Rays and are going into the bottom of the 7th with a one run lead. It’s June, the team is riddled with injuries, and we’re doing pretty well. It’s good to be a Mariners fan.

Posted in 1 | Leave a comment

State Of The Section Lately

The Mariners are currently playing a game in Minneapolis to make up a game that got rained out earlier in the season. You would think that in 2018, a trillion dollar industry wouldn’t allow the weather to stop games anywhere in either league; but apparently some cities with far more inclement weather than Seattle ever has during baseball season disagree. I will probably be whinging about this until they fix it or I die, whichever comes first.

So much has gone on over the last month, and I haven’t been able to keep up. Ichiro’s retirement/transition to something called “Special Assistant to the Chairman” (?!?) is the most notable, but this situation didn’t hit me as hard as I thought it might. It is nice to have Ichiro back in Seattle, even still. Due to a lot of the games in April being away and earlier during the day when I couldn’t watch (or listen; still have that same problem at the new job with AM radio signals and computer equipment), I was, most thankfully, spared from having to watch a lot of his reported performance issues. I saw some great catches in person, but it sounds like it was time for him to step back. I’m happy that he could do that in a dignified and graceful manner while still being part of the team without taking up a roster spot. I would expect nothing less from him than the same class and humility he has always shown here. His continued presence is an intangible, but I can’t help but feel like he helps morale in the best way possible. I’m glad it worked out the way it did. I think him leaving the first time and getting emotional about it during his press conference sort of prepared me for this, which was a slightly more matter-of-fact and not-so-sad departure.

Two other big things so far this year, of course, have to do with our boy James Paxton and his 16 strikeouts on Wednesday May 2nd in a 3-2 loss against Oakland. That was also Ichiro’s last game, so the day after was bittersweet because I was still riding the high of being at that game for the pitching, then sad about Ichiro’s announcement. Pax pitched a solid 7 innings allowing only 5 hits and a walk, and everything else was strikeouts until Juan Nicasio and then Edwin Diaz took over and the score went a little sideways, but as far as a loss it was a terrifically fun game to be at with the Maple Grove, and I’ve had worse times at a ballpark before. Paxton then proceeded to travel to Toronto to no-hit the Blue Jays, the second Canadian ever to throw a no-hitter, and the third pitcher in recent Mariners history to do so (the other two being Felix and Hisashi Iwakuma, of course). There is another statistic associated with this victory, but I can’t recall it off the top of my head. His return to Safeco this Saturday was supposed to be Friday, but then we got rained out in Detroit, and that threw everything off. No matter, the Grove will be there in left field for his start. We’ll also be there on Friday for Felix’s start becasue of reasons I can’t go into right now. The Mariners are providing a special ticket package with $20 tickets in View Reserved, which is about $15 less than those seats are normally, so I hope a lot of people take them up on it. The King’s Court will be in session as always and you never know what you might see.

I may be in the minority, but all in all I am pleased with the beginning of the Mariners season. We’re third just behind the Angels and way ahead of the Rangers, and still above .500. And while we are up by a run after what has been kind of a grueling game after a rain delay as I type this out, if we lose this game it will not hurt us much. I am concerned about Robinson Cano’s broken hand from the other day, since he will need surgery which will take him away from us for a while, but we seem to have several options to cover our bases. No pun intended, but here we are. I haven’t been able to get to a Rainiers game yet this year, but Daniel Vogelbach has been absolutely crazy in Triple A, and it would be nice to see him up here a time or two before the year is over. It would be nice if Guillermo Heredia could also see some more major league playing time, and of course Gordon Beckham just got called up to fill in with Cano out. Some kid named Cameron Perkins is also seeing some happy days down in Tacoma as well.

Lastly, I have been involved in rugby and the Seawolves down at Starfire. It’s a fascinating game, and after a chat with one of the bartenders at Edgar’s Lower a few weeks ago, I understand what I’ve been watching a lot more. The crowd there is always sellout, and I got an email earlier today saying that their entire season is sold. Judging by the stands in New Orleans on Saturday morning, Seattle might once again have the fan advantage, just like we do with soccer. It’s nice to see so many people embrace a game that is largely not known to most Americans, and be so enthusiastic doing so. Starfire is a cozy little stadium, and the season is short – four home games – so it’s easy to incorporate into my baseball schedule. I plan on being a season ticketholder next year as well, provided the front office doesn’t go nuts and jack up the prices.

And that’s about it lately; I’ve been enjoying the return of baseball and the recently-warming weather, though it is about 80F in our living room right now. I can’t complain too much; when I was in the stands in two sweaters and a peacoat, this was all I could think about. I can go this weekend with just a t-shirt and be perfectly comfortable. Summer is the best!

Posted in 1 | Leave a comment

Mariners Commercials Are Here!

Watching James Paxton throw at the San Francisco Giants, with the smallest chants of “Eh! Eh! Eh!” coming through on the TV broadcast. Ichiro has left the game already with some sort of (hopefully minor) injury that must have happened during a commercial break because I was sat right here and didn’t see anything happen to him; the Mariners were up in the bottom of the first inning, and Ichiro was shown in a review clip being taken off the field sitting upright in the front seat of a cart. Hoping it’s nothing big, and wishing him a speedy recovery. Hopefully some stretching and his wife’s curry will heal him right up.

Every year we wait for the Mariners commercials. They mark another step towards the beginning of the regular season, and every year, they are subject to varying levels of scrutiny by the fan base. Every year, too, my hope is that they can air all 4-6 of them all season, since stopping the airing of one means the player featured therein has been injured, was traded, or was sent down to Tacoma. My favorite of the past few years is probably still the K-Swag commercial, specifically for the crazy expressions on the marketers’ faces when they were trying to introduce Kyle Seager to their particular brand of…branding. This year, there was not a single one that didn’t make me smile.

This year starts off with Work Related Injury. A Kansas City pitcher talks to his doctor about the dangers of having to face Nelson Cruz and his dingers. I like this one for its simplicity, and Nellie’s little grin at the end.

Second – and my personal favorite – is The Art of the Frame, featuring one of the most fun  pitcher/catcher combos to watch, Felix and Mike Zunino. Players gather to reflect on the art of Zunino’s pitch framing, and Felix’s ability to paint the zone. Winning line goes to Mitch Hanniger for “As a hitter, I find that offensive” – a sentiment that evokes everything from social media opinions to actual art critiques. Brilliantly played. Felix will just paint more.

Next up, starter and Maple Grove favorite James Paxton finally gets his own commercial with Big Maple. Now, I don’t know who in that production team knows what about how the Maple Grove started, but I personally would like to think that the crack about the Blue Jays is a small tribute to our little cheering section, since the first Maple Grove did indeed happen the day in 2017 Paxton started against Toronto. And some of us wouldn’t mind too badly if the little eggs were full of Orioles.

Fourth up is Mound Visit, where members of the Texas Rangers are heartily assured by Robinson Cano that there is very little they can do to stop his bat from meeting the ball. Not so much funny as a very confident look at one of our best hitters.

And finally, the one that seems to be getting most of the attention, Flip. Try as he might, Kyle Seager just can’t work a mane like Ben Gamel can. If Seager has to deal with a neck injury this year, we’ll all know why.

And of course, it’s not a complete commercial collection without a two minute long behind-the-scenes/blooper reel. Baseball players are not actors, but it’s always clearly in good fun, and as always, the marketing team has done right by both the team and the fans here. Well done, ladies and gentlemen, well done.

As I am wrapping this up, Pax has been replaced by Christian Bergman, and the broadcasters are mentioning another injury, this time to Jean Segura for hamstring tightness. Small hurdles, and hopefully easily overcome with time over the next few weeks. Felix is rumored to be in line for the rotation for Opening Day, but there has to be “no hiccup” in his recovery per Aaron Goldsmith just now on TV. Either Felix or Pax I would be totally content with starting that day. Hell, who am I kidding; I’ll just be happy to be in a baseball park surrounded by some of the best fans and friends I could have hoped to make when I first started watching the game. Three more Thursdays, friends, it’s nearly time!


Posted in 1 | Leave a comment

Ichiro, 4Mom, And The Maple Grove’s Reappearance

I think it’s just time to admit to myself that my writing here is never going to be as prolific as it once was. The job I moved to back in November demands a lot of me, and when I’m not there, I’m trying to unwind and not think or do much; but I still want to maintain this site, so writing may be sporadic, but it’ll still be here. I think, too, not being able to go to FanFest this year took some of the wind out of my sails, but tonight marks the first time this month I’ve been able to sit down and watch anything to do with Spring Training, so what better time than now to sit here on the couch and spout my Big Dumb Opinions?

First up: Ichiro’s return. I cried at my desk during the bits of a press conference would allow me to watch on my phone. I hoped it would happen in 2012 when he left mid-season, but years with the Yankees and Marlins and then getting bits and pieces of information about his declining hit numbers, I just figured at the least they might do a one-day signing ceremonial thing or we’d see him again when they finally retire number 51. I was in shock all day Tuesday when I first got the news. It was comforting, to see him again, and emotional to see him with Jerry Dipoto during the presser yesterday, hoisting his jersey. Like when you haven’t seen a friend in years and you see each other and immediately start cracking jokes and picking up the conversation as if you were never apart. I know that time marches over us all, and he won’t be the same Ichiro he was when he was here for so long, but it doesn’t matter to me. Ichiro is basically my Ken Griffey Jr, my Edgar Martinez; when he retires I plan to start saving up for a trip to Cooperstown, and I plan to get the best travel package available. I also plan to wear some big sunglasses because I will be crying during his induction speech. I am also aware that there is a very bold division between those of us who love this situation and those that really don’t. It’s everyone’s prerogative to love or hate any given move their team makes, and I harbor no ill will against anyone who is not on board with this; but I am very on board. You could do much worse with a replacement for Ben Gamel. And the home opener is going to be absolutely electric.

Dee Gordon is rumored to have made the switch from infielder to outfielder like a knife through hot butter. I know Gordon was sort of lukewarm with being sent here and being converted from his original position at short or second, but I’m hoping that the addition of Ichiro will lighen his mood about being sent to our isolated little corner here in Seattle, and it sounds like he will make a speedy addition to our baserunning crew as well as having a good throwing arm. My main disappointment with not having FanFest was that I was hoping they’d get Gordon to show up and take some questions at Dugout Dialogue; but I’ll have to wait for post-game interviews, and by that time I will likely have a feel for who he is as a player anyway. All I can say is that I’m looking forward to it.

For those who might not know, Braden Bishop, our minor leaguer CF, has started a sort of fire among some Mariners fans and minor league players from other teams. Bishop’s mother apparently is battling early onset Alzheimer’s disease, so he started a charity  called 4Mom. Players are choosing a dollar amount they will donate to the charity per hit or per strikeout. A small group of fans has started a player adoption for Spring Training (and perhaps beyond) and plan to also donate accordingly. I grabbed up Mike Zunino, and am good for a dollar a hit. So far I understand I owe at least a buck for a home run last week, but Lookout Landing’s Kate Preusser is keeping a spreadsheet, and I know that at least a bunch of people from the Maple Grove will be donating, and have claimed other plaeyrs. I may keep it up through the season. I don’t see any reason not to, and I am hoping for good things for Zunino this year.

Speaking of the Maple Grove…yes, we will be back this year. Due to Felix’s arm injury from that line drive last week, we are anticipating that James Paxton will probably get Opening Day duties, and we do plan to be there out in left field. Hillary is already designing Eh cards, Daniel is already working on signs (and signs for the Jays series, as well, of course), and we have a block of tickets somewhere – I am unsure where, but it will probably be announced a few days prior to the home opener, and there will be quite a few surprised people who are already sat in that section who will find themselves part of the Grove. It may be sufficient to say that I am really looking forward to the start of the season. It is about time for baseball to be back.




Posted in 1 | Leave a comment

Monday? Mariners!

Happy 2018 to everyone who is still with me – all five of you.

I wanted to write about the winter meetings, but sadly they had all the excitement of a wet firework, so I opted instead to concentrate on my holiday month, and eating and drinking as much as humanly possible while hoping that some of the rumors connected to the Mariners might come to fruition. Spoiler alert; they did not. The one move that Jerry Dipoto did make over the last month involved Dee Gordon for some prospects and cash with the Marlins. Gordon has been connected with PEDs as recently as last year which is disappointing, but I have learned to temper my disappointment on this topic (though I still maintain that there is a HUGE difference between steroids and amphetamines because I’m familiar with pharmacy, but I digress). There isn’t much I can do about it, and I assume that the front office will provide Gordon with some information about the Mariners clubhouse culture that they have worked so hard to cultivate over the last few years since Jack Zduriencik’s departure. I don’t know much about what happns behind clubhouse doors outside of the glimpses we are allowed into spring training bonding events, Rookie Day, and the like, but I would assume that players are encouraged to not use steroids, or at the very least, not to get caught with them. The last thing we need is a player suspension, given last year’s injury-fest, so maybe we can steer clear of PEDs for a bit

I vaguely remember reading something indicating that Gordon wasn’t super happy about the trade, and I get that; we don’t have an Ichiro or a Giancarlo Stanton or a Christian Yelich. I understand that generally speaking, the Mariners are not a destination team. To top it off, it looks like we’re going to possibly platoon (someone let me know if I’m off here) him in the outfield, rather than maintain his second base or even short stop position. I would imagine that is a bit difficult to get used to, being switched around without having much of a say in the matter. But Robinson Cano is still an everyday player at second, and we are still getting plenty of work out of Jean Segura at short. I do hope that if the case is truly that Gordon has any negative feelings towards this development, we as fans can change his mind this year. I am looking forward to seeing what he can do. Per his numbers, we’re not getting a power guy, but a guy who does do some hitting and some base stealing. I’m OK with that. I have in recent years become a huge fan of smaller more strategic ball playing. The occasional home run is never frowned upon, but getting to an opposing pitcher can be such a treat, and it’s a treat we don’t seem to see very often. I’m ready.

The Mariners Caravan has started! Usually the harbinger of Fan Fest every year, the group kicked off today out in Yakima at the SunDome. I have never been able to attend a single Caravan. Even if I got an hour for lunch, I would really be pushing it to get to Bellevue and back before I had to get to work again. I gave some serious thought once to trying to get to University Village to see RA Dickey years back, but it just wasn’t going to happen. Seattle traffic is a cruel mistress that only gets more cruel as time goes on. As for FanFest, woof. The new grass they put in last year after the end of the season will not be grown well enough to have fans stepping all over it to play catch and bat tees and zip line. While I think most fans would be totally cool with having it at WAMU Theater or some other larger venue like a lot of other teams, I can also appreciate the fact that the Ms want to maintain that in-the-park atmosphere, and it just wouldn’t be the same indoors somewhere. I mean, I’d still take it, but half the fun of the thing is being in the park, and I like the dedication they have to maintaining that for everyone. The other bummer part was that I figured they’d invite Dee Gordon out to introduce him to everyone and answer questions; the fan questions most years are pretty generic, some are funny, but it’s the way I get a feel for the new guys, when we are lucky enough to have them come out. Next year, I may have to go to both days to make up for this loss.

Mariners Mondays are currently on, and the Mariners are lighting up the Houston Astros  during the 2017 home opener. I am huddled under a blanket and remembering how cold I was that day, sitting in left field; but I’d give a lot to go do that now, so while rerun sports is not something I’m a big fan of, I am welcoming the little bit of it I get to watch because this year it’s going to be a longer than usual wait to head back to my big, beautiful, black-domed metal summer home.

Posted in 1 | Leave a comment

“Buying Championships” Is Harder Than It Looks

For the purposes of this article, all WAR measurements are through Baseball Reference.


So the Dodgers are in the World Series, and to some degree they are wearing the Black Hat of the villain. Though they haven’t won the World Series since 1988, their payroll tops baseball, and those of us who have gone our whole lives hating the Yankees for buying championships may well have a distaste for the Dodgers for using the same playbook.

Continue reading

Posted in 1 | Leave a comment

Daniel Riffs on Expansion and Realignment

If you haven’t been following Twitter much today, you might’ve missed an article from Baseball America commenting on the possibility of Major League Baseball expansion, realignment, and schedule changes. Part of it includes speculation that Portland, Oregon would attract a team, which I’m skeptical of (and so is the principal author of this blog), but that’s kind of beside the point.


I have a bit of a wish list for any expansion of the league and the playoffs, and I’d like to share that with you now.


I’d like to see two leagues of 16 teams each, with each league split into two divisions of 8. The two division winners would be entered into the Division Series. In addition, four Wild Card teams would be included in the playoffs and they would play a one-and-done game to reach the Division Series, hosted by the two non-division-winning teams with the best records.


Perhaps the thought that makes this most attractive to me is that winning the division competing directly against seven other teams would be a significant achievement. Having direct competition with so many teams makes it similar to winning the pennant in the pre-expansion era. It would also bring it back in line with division champions from 1969 until 1994 when expansion and divisional realignment gave us three divisions instead of two.


Bringing the teams-per-division into alignment with historical norms would give us a better measurement of team dominance over time. Twenty-nine of the Yankees’ 40 pennants happened before divisional play; while this was certainly dominant, the league itself was only eight teams at the time. Being one-in-eight I think is worth celebrating, where being one-in-five doesn’t carry the same weight.


In the meantime, keeping wild cards in existence prevents the fate of the 103-win 1993 San Francisco Giants, who failed to make the playoffs because Atlanta collected 104 wins. It also maintains the ratio of playoff teams we’re used to seeing over the last decade of baseball. Lastly, it helps maintain the primacy of the MLB regular season. Over the past few seasons, I’ve mostly grown to like the Wild Card Game because of the benefit it gives to the division winner.


The downside I can see here is that having four Wild Card teams pushes ever closer to the NBA problem were sub-.500 teams can make the postseason (A 38-44 Brooklyn team was the last one to do so in the 2014-15 season). My counterargument in the near-term is that an expansion team in each league will probably soak up some extra losses for a few years and middling teams may pick up a game or two and avoid dropping below .500. Perhaps a Monte Carlo Simulation can tell us if this is actually more or less likely with more teams.


What seems clear is that MLB is excited to keep fans invested later and later into the season, and having these extra playoff spots may be a way to do that. All that’s well and good, but I’m not convinced that the extra spots have actually driven up attendance any appreciable amount. I’ll use some data: This season, the Mariners averaged almost 25,450 for their August 14-16 Baltimore series, which fell on a Monday through Wednesday after they has been swept by the Angels over Edgar weekend. At this point, the M’s were two back of the Angels for the second Wild Card spot. Look ahead a bit to their series against Oakland on the Friday-to-Sunday of Labor Day Weekend and they only averaged 22,724. Out of 15 home games in September, only four cracked 25,000, and two of those games were Fan Appreciation Night and King Felix Funko Pop Night. On the other hand, the M’s only cracked 25,000 once in the final month of 2015 on Fan Appreciation Night as well.


Anyhow, moving aside from the playoff eligibility talk, I want to keep the American League and National League designations for as long as I can, along with the DH in the AL only. One thing I love about baseball is that there is a rule distinction between the two leagues, and the organization of the teams is more than simply “legacy,” like it is in the NFL. From an outside perspective, the NFL’s AFC and NFC conferences seem arbitrary, though they have preserved rivalries like Dallas vs. New York and Green Bay vs. Chicago. I don’t want baseball’s American and National Leagues to suffer the same fate.


I’ll get off my soapbox in a second, but since I’m here, I’d also like to eliminate Interleague Play. Unfortunately, I have my doubts that would ever happen. It seems that there’s too much money in it and everyone has more or less gotten used to the idea at this point. That said, I think removing Interleague Play could create more excitement once again for the All-Star Game and World Series. Maybe it could wash.


As far as the actual cities go? I’m not sure I could care significantly less. It would be nice to have a nearby rival, or at least another team on the west coast so the Mariners don’t always have to travel so far, and I’d be a proponent of having a club back in Montreal, but I’d much rather have two divisions in each league instead.

Posted in 1 | Leave a comment